Sunday, September 20, 2009

Idol Review - Top 10

Really struggling to care. So are the kids. The documentary on the ABC was more interesting to us all, so we watched that for the first half hour.

Happy that Casey went. He needed to.

Sabrina - A bit yelly.

Toby - Not convinced by his changed between lower and higher register

Kim - Her main problem is that she's not as good or as interesting as Hayley. Not sure how she'll overcome this.

Stan - No idea what he was singing about. What's with the hoody?

James - I'm a fan. The slight country thing works for me.

Scott - A train wreck. Embarrassing. Song far too hard for him.

Nathan - A girl's song. Sorry, it just is. I think the camp comments were way unhelpful for a 16 year old.

Kate - It was probably really good. The judges thought so. I can't get past the hat, the shirt or the cliche 'rise above'. Sorry.

Tim - A stupid song choice.

Hayley - Liked her less than last week. Why do R&B?

Based on performances, Scott should go. But he'll probably get the sympathy vote.

What did you think?

1 comment: